Central Market Analysis
Who Is Buying — And Why
Central New York’s luxury clientele ranges from city‑weary Manhattan professionals to Sunshine State residents seeking seasonal relief, but recent interest from hedge‑fund partners, tech founders and C‑suite executives signals a true globalization of the buyer pool. For some, Finger Lakes estates are part lifestyle play, part tax strategy, as high earners look to establish residency outside New York City while still enjoying proximity to the metro area.
In Skaneateles, estimated property taxes of around $11,000 per $1 million in value compare favorably with New York City’s much higher burdens, strengthening the case for relocating or at least shifting primary residency upstate. Combined with remote and hybrid work, this has allowed buyers who once needed to live within commuting distance of Manhattan to prioritize space, water and privacy instead.
As for local luxury in New Jersey, the brokers are describing current buyers as focused on privacy, water frontage, acreage and multigenerational “legacy” assets, with some purchasers paying nearly 50% above asking price for rare, turnkey waterfront homes they intend to keep in the family. This segment now attracts not only New Yorkers and Floridians but also ultra–high‑net‑worth global buyers who compare Finger Lakes pricing of up to roughly $1,700 per square foot with global ultra‑prime markets that can exceed $6,500 per square foot.
Central New York vs. Central New Jersey (Ocean & Monmouth)
Central New York’s luxury boom looks very different when set beside Central New Jersey’s established high‑end coastal markets in Monmouth and Ocean Counties. While Central New York is transitioning from “affordable alternative” to emerging luxury destination, Monmouth and Ocean already function as longstanding upscale corridors tied directly to the New York–Philadelphia metro wealth base.
Market Structure and Pricing
- Central New York’s median list prices in markets like Syracuse and Rochester remain in the mid‑$200,000s, even after recent surges, so seven‑figure properties are rare and highly concentrated around lakes and historic enclaves. By contrast, Monmouth County’s luxury segment alone includes hundreds of listings, with one major brokerage showing roughly 700–800 “luxury” properties for sale and a median list price near $769,000.
- Ocean County likewise shows a broad high‑end base, with one large platform reporting over 500 luxury listings and a median list price in the low‑$500,000s, plus individual trophy properties topping $18 million along the Barnegat Bay and barrier island shorelines.
Lifestyle and Location
- Central New York’s appeal is anchored in four‑season recreation, vineyard and lake culture, and a slower‑paced countryside lifestyle within a day’s drive of Manhattan. Luxury buyers here often seek secluded acreage, deep‑water frontage and low visibility rather than bustling downtowns.
- Monmouth and Ocean Counties pair suburban neighborhoods and horse‑farm country with oceanfront, bayfront and riverfront communities, offering New York City and North Jersey commuters beaches, marinas and rail/highway access in addition to second‑home and resort amenities.
Supply, Velocity and Competition
- Central New York’s luxury pool is numerically small, so even modest demand produces intense competition and outsized price jumps when rare, well‑located properties hit the market. Bidding wars that drive final prices 40% or more above ask are not unheard of on pristine Finger Lakes waterfront.
- Monmouth and Ocean Counties show far more depth of inventory at and above $1 million, but well‑priced coastal and commuter‑friendly homes still move quickly, with one major brokerage reporting typical market results.
If you have any questions about this information or title insurance, please contact Ralph Aponte: 732.914.1400.
Counsellors Title Agency, www.counsellorstitle.net, founded in 1996, is one of New Jersey’s most respected title agencies, serving all 21 New Jersey counties with title insurance, clearing title, escrow, tidelands searches, and closing and settlement services for commercial or industrial properties, waterfront properties and marinas, condominiums, townhouses or residential single-family homes. Counsellors Title also features its own Attorney Settlement Assistance Program™ [ASAP], which is an individual resource customized to fit the needs specifically of real estate attorneys, including, Documentation, Preparation, Disbursement of Funds, Attendance at Closing, HUD Preparation or Post-Closing Matters.
Connect with Ralph on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ralphaponte/