Central State Market Shifts – Part 3

Part 3: The Luxury Segment: High Demand, Limited Supply

Market Characteristics
Luxury Inventory:

• Central New York: Rochester had just 32 active million-dollar listings in November 2025, representing a tiny fraction of its overall market of 752 monthly listings. The entire luxury segment is highly specialized with very limited options.
• New Jersey Shore: Monmouth County alone has over 800 luxury listings, though still insufficient to meet demand. The shore’s luxury market is more established with deeper inventory.

Days on Market:

• Central New York: Million-dollar homes in Rochester stay on market for a median of 63 days, well below the 76-day national average.
• New Jersey Shore: Premium properties in communities like Bay Head and Mantoloking sell in approximately 42 days, demonstrating even stronger demand dynamics in the most exclusive locations.

Buyer Profiles:

• Central New York: Attracting value-conscious buyers, remote workers, Micron-related professionals, and investors anticipating dramatic appreciation. Properties appeal to those seeking space and affordability while building equity.
• New Jersey Shore: Drawing affluent professionals, ultra-high-net-worth individuals, second-home buyers, and those prioritizing lifestyle, water access, and proximity to major cities. Cash transactions dominate the luxury tier.

Monmouth County currently has over 800 luxury homes (priced at $775,000 and above) on the market, with properties spending an average of 40 days before sale. However, this inventory represents only a fraction of the overall market activity, creating intense competition among qualified buyers.

Ocean County’s luxury market shows similar dynamics. In exclusive shore communities like Bay Head and Mantoloking, properties are in particularly high demand. Between January and mid-July 2025, 49 new luxury listings came to market in these barrier island towns, totaling over $201 million in list volume, with a median list price of $3.2 million. These properties are selling at a brisk pace—averaging just 42 days on market—demonstrating robust buyer confidence and engagement.

Million-dollar homes along the Jersey Shore are selling faster than comparable properties nationwide. While the national average for million-dollar homes is 76 days on market, premium properties in Monmouth and Ocean Counties are moving in 42-63 days, signaling exceptional demand even as affordability remains strained nationally.

Investment Perspective
For real estate investors and homebuyers, these markets offer distinctly different opportunities:

Central New York represents a high-growth, value-play strategy. With median prices in the $200,000-$300,000 range and double-digit appreciation forecasts, investors can enter at relatively low price points with significant upside potential. The Micron development creates a once-in-a-generation economic catalyst that could reshape the region’s long-term trajectory.

The Jersey Shore offers an established luxury market with steady appreciation, strong rental income potential (in permitted areas), and the enduring appeal of coastal living. While entry prices are substantially higher, the market benefits from land scarcity, generational wealth transfer, and proximity to the nation’s largest concentration of high-net-worth individuals in the New York metropolitan area.

The Path Forward
The fundamental driver of both markets’ success is simple: limited supply meeting strong demand. In New Jersey, developable waterfront land is essentially exhausted in the most desirable communities, creating permanent supply constraints. In Central New York, the Micron development will stimulate housing demand that current supply cannot accommodate.

If you have any questions about this information or title insurance, please contact Ralph Aponte: 732.914.1400.

Connect with Ralph on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ralphaponte/